"It is often said that New York is a city for only the very rich and the very poor. It is less often said that New York is also, at least for those of us who came there from somewhere else, a city for only the very young. For the loners and creators." - Joan Didion, Slouching Toward Bethlehem
I wonder why I am attracted to the city because sometimes I don't feel worthy. Mostly though because I am too sensitive, too easily swayed by illusions and romance. Or so I thought. I thought I was too sweet for the edge but I understand the attraction now. I love to watch people try to be tough. I love the varying gaits, the city in squares, the psychology of skyscrapers. Most of all I love people, the strangeness of distance and proximity. Corruption and compassion. The seriousness of suits and slum swagger.
Tony Kushner said that New York City is "the strange place, the melting pot where nothing melted." I believe it, and people may fear it. But "it" is only a fear of understanding. Those who can see the beauty and tragedy of small city scenes and break down movement and pace are tough enough and worthy of this city.
All previous reflection is inspired by an article I read about Paul McDonough's New York City photography between 1968-1978. His photos have those city subtleties. I feel no distance from his eccentric characters, only jealousy in missing his moments of human revelation. He makes pictorial sense of strangeness. "You were not looking for photographs, but for the raw material that would make you want to photograph; the gesture or expression that demanded to be recorded. You were in the moment and you didn’t judge or qualify."
I am particularly interested in his photography in contrast to Californian culture and imagery during this time. I have been indulging in Didion, and realized I often abstract history because it is the easiest thing to do, generalizing a decade and not dissecting it. So it's been fun switching between time zones, traveling East Coast and West Coast through the words and photographs. All in all people are people, but cross the country, watch the continent become a coast and dregs of dryness, and then a sea, and watch people change. That is the beauty of humanity. We change but never really change.
Paul McDonough - New York City
Paul McDonough -New York City
Paul McDonough - New York City
Paul McDonough -New York City
Paul McDonough -New York City
Annie Leibovitz - California